Decoding the Interplay of Lighting and Spatial Dynamics: A Simulation-Based Case Study Analysis across Diverse Building Orientations

Nijah Akram; Sajjad Mubin; Ayesha Mehmood Malik; Rimsha Imran; Maryam Jamil

doi:10.63278/10.63278/mme.v31.1

Authors

Nijah Akram PhD Scholar, Department of Architectural Engineering and Design, Faculty of Civil Engineering, University of Engineering and Technology, Lahore, Pakistan
Sajjad Mubin Professor and Chair, Architectural Engineering and Design Department, Faculty of Civil Engineering. University of Engineering and Technology, Lahore, Pakistan
Ayesha Mehmood Malik Associate Professor, School of Architecture, Faculty of Arts and Architecture, The University of Lahore, Pakistan
Rimsha Imran Lecturer, Interior Design Department, Lahore College for Women University, Lahore, Pakistan
Maryam Jamil Lecturer, Architecture Department, Lahore College for Women University, Lahore, Pakistan

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.63278/10.63278/mme.v31.1

Keywords:

Lighting Patterns; Revit Simulation; Building Orientations; Spatial-temporal Dynamics.

Abstract

In contrast to artificial light sources, which can be calibrated for specific luminous effects, daylight is a dynamic source that generates varying shadow patterns and brightness levels. Despite the diversity in scale and complexity of daylight studies, this research extended spatial and temporal dimensions. This research predicts the interplay of spatial-temporal dynamics and daylight in replicated buildings across diverse orientations. This study employs integrated measurement tools, Autodesk Revit simulation, statistical analysis, and Heliodon simulations. Results have shown that spatial dimensions consistently affect daylighting levels, underscoring the importance of architectural design and orientation. Seasonal effects on daylighting vary spatially, impacting daylight inconsistently, while time intervals appear non-significant, possibly causing regional daylighting differences. In conclusion, building orientations significantly influence daylight distribution, and architectural choices are crucial in maintaining consistent daylight throughout varied spatial-temporal dynamics. This study advances the scientific comprehension of spatial-temporal elements in sustaining consistent lighting patterns across diverse building orientations.

References

Yao, Y., et al., Simulation-based analysis of window paper effects on daylighting of traditional Beijing siheyuan. Architectural Science Review, 2024: p. 1-13.

Thakur, R. and A. Sharma, ASPECTS AND ISSUES OF DAYLIGHT PERFORMANCE IN OFFICES: A REVIEW STUDY. CAHIERS MAGELLANES-NS, 2024. 6(1): p. 1312-1320.

Jiang, C., et al., A multilayer perceptron-based fast sunlight assessment for the conceptual design of residential neighborhoods under Chinese policy. Building and Environment, 2023. 244: p. 110739.

Nikookar, N., et al., Investigating the Impact of Combined Daylight and Electric Light on Human Perception of Indoor Spaces. Sustainability, 2024. 16(9): p. 3691.

Wu, Y., et al., Influence of thermal and lighting factors on human perception and work performance in simulated underground environment. Science of the Total Environment, 2022. 828: p. 154455.

Bellazzi, A., et al., Virtual reality for assessing visual quality and lighting perception: A systematic review. Building and Environment, 2022. 209: p. 108674.

Du, X., Y. Zhang, and S. Zhao, Research on interaction effect of thermal, light and acoustic environment on human comfort in waiting hall of high-speed railway station. Building and environment, 2022. 207: p. 108494.

Ravn, M., et al., Simulating physiological potentials of daylight variables in lighting design. Sustainability, 2022. 14(2): p. 881.

Pathirage, L.Y. and N.G.R. Perera, Daylight variability and human perception. 2021.

Al-Yasiri, Q. and M. Szabó, Numerical analysis of thin building envelope-integrated phase change material towards energy-efficient buildings in severe hot location. Sustainable Cities and Society, 2023. 89: p. 104365.

Kangazian, A. and S.Z.E. Razavi, Multi-criteria evaluation of daylight control systems of office buildings considering daylighting, glare and energy consumption. Solar Energy, 2023. 263: p. 111928.

Zoure, A.N. and P.V. Genovese, Implementing natural ventilation and daylighting strategies for thermal comfort and energy efficiency in office buildings in Burkina Faso. Energy Reports, 2023. 9: p. 3319-3342.

Rea, M.S. and M.G. Figueiro, Light as a circadian stimulus for architectural lighting. Lighting research & technology, 2018. 50(4): p. 497-510.

Amundadottir, M.L., et al., A human-centric approach to assess daylight in buildings for non-visual health potential, visual interest and gaze behavior. Building and Environment, 2017. 113: p. 5-21.

Shemiranib, F.M.-S.M.M. and M. Tahbazc, Evaluation and Analysis of the Efficiency of Dynamic Metrics Evaluating Daylight Performance (Daylight Autonomy and Useful Daylight Illuminance) through Sensitivity Analysis; Case Study: Elementary Classroom in Tehran. 2020.

Yu, C., et al., Quantifying the spatial, temporal, angular and spectral structure of effective daylight in perceptually meaningful ways. Optics Express, 2023. 31(5): p. 8953-8974.

Rockcastle, S. and M. Andersen, Measuring the dynamics of contrast & daylight variability in architecture: A proof-of-concept methodology. Building and Environment, 2014. 81: p. 320-333.

Yu, C., et al., Spatial and temporal dynamics of effective daylight in natural scenes. Journal of Vision, 2022. 22(14): p. 3984-3984.

Wasilewski, S., et al., A critical literature review of spatio-temporal simulation methods for daylight glare assessment. SDAR* Journal of Sustainable Design & Applied Research, 2019. 7(1): p. 4.

Atzeri, A.M., et al., Comfort metrics for an integrated evaluation of buildings performance. Energy and Buildings, 2016. 127: p. 411-424.

van Duijnhoven, J., M.P.J. Aarts, and H.S.M. Kort, Personal lighting conditions of office workers: An exploratory field study. Lighting Research & Technology, 2021. 53(4): p. 285-310.

Chamilothori, K., J. Wienold, and M. Andersen. Daylight patterns as a means to influence the spatial ambience: a preliminary study. International Network Ambiances; University of Thessaly.

Jakubiec, J.A. Validation of simplified visual discomfort calculations.

Jakubiec, J.A., G. Quek, and T. Srisamranrungruang, Towards subjectivity in annual climate-based daylight metrics. 2018.

Chamilothori, K., et al. Effects of dappled light patterns on preference, fascination, and restoration in an online study.

Houser, K.W., Cloudy with a Chance of Sunbeams. 2018, Taylor & Francis. p. 107-110.

Andersen, M. and S. Rockcastle, Annual Dynamics Of Daylight Variability and Contrast. A simulation-Based Approach to Quantifying Visual Effects in Architecture” Springer Brief In Computer Science, 2014.

Pastilha, R. and A. Hurlbert, Seeing and sensing temporal variations in natural daylight. Progress in Brain Research, 2022. 273(1): p. 275-301.

Ayoub, M., A review on machine learning algorithms to predict daylighting inside buildings. Solar energy, 2020. 202: p. 249-275.

Ayoub, M., A multivariate regression to predict daylighting and energy consumption of residential buildings within hybrid settlements in hot-desert climates. Indoor and built environment, 2019. 28(6): p. 848-866.

Reinhart, C.F., J.A. Jakubiec, and D. Ibarra, Definition of a reference office for standardized evaluations of dynamic façade and lighting technologies. 2013.

Ayoub, M., Self-organizing profiles to characterize representative temporal settings for daylight simulations. Solar Energy, 2021. 214: p. 248-267.

Lee, J., M. Boubekri, and F. Liang, Impact of building design parameters on daylighting metrics using an analysis, prediction, and optimization approach based on statistical learning technique. Sustainability, 2019. 11(5): p. 1474.

Sonawane, M.B. and S.Y. Mhaske, PREDICTING DAYLIGHT ILLUMINANCE IN URBAN CITY USING STATISTICAL REGRESSION TECHNIQUES. Journal of Engineering Science and Technology, 2018. 13(7): p. 2181-2194.

Al-Dossary, A.M. and D.D. Kim, A study of design variables in daylight and energy performance in residential buildings under hot climates. Energies, 2020. 13(21): p. 5836.

Natephra, W., et al., Integrating building information modeling and virtual reality development engines for building indoor lighting design. Visualization in Engineering, 2017. 5(1): p. 1-21.

Zhang, J., et al., BIM-based architectural analysis and optimization for construction 4.0 concept (a comparison). Ain Shams Engineering Journal, 2023. 14(6): p. 102110.

Yan, W., et al., Interfacing BIM with building thermal and daylighting modeling. 2013.

Kota, S., et al., Building Information Modeling (BIM)-based daylighting simulation and analysis. Energy and buildings, 2014. 81: p. 391-403.

Stavrakantonaki, M. Daylight performance simulations and 3D modeling in BIM and non-BIM tools. Faculty of Architecture, Delft University of Technology; eCAADe (Education ….

David B. Dalumo, Y.-W.L., Comparative Study on Computer Simulation of Solar Shading

Performance with Heliodon and Artificial Sky. Journal of Daylighting, 2021. 8(1): p. 50-64.

Safikhani, S., et al., Immersive virtual reality for extending the potential of building information modeling in architecture, engineering, and construction sector: Systematic review. International Journal of Digital Earth, 2022. 15(1): p. 503-526.

Assila, A., et al. Integration of augmented, virtual and mixed reality with building information modeling: a systematic review. Springer.

Tahmasebinia, F., et al., Implementation of BIM energy analysis and monte carlo simulation for estimating building energy performance based on regression approach: A case study. Buildings, 2022. 12(4): p. 449.

Izmir Tunahan, G., et al., Evaluation of Daylight Perception Assessment Methods. Frontiers in Psychology, 2022. 13: p. 805796.

Chi, D.A., D. Moreno, and J. Navarro, Statistical methods applied to optimize perforated façade design for daylight availability. Journal of Architectural Engineering, 2019. 25(1): p. 04018034.

Tysiac, P., et al., Combination of terrestrial laser scanning and UAV photogrammetry for 3D modelling and degradation assessment of heritage building based on a lighting analysis: case study—St. Adalbert Church in Gdansk, Poland. Heritage Science, 2023. 11(1): p. 1-14.

Nasyrov, V., et al., Building information models as input for building energy performance simulation–the current state of industrial implementations. Building information models as input for building energy performance simulation–the current state of industrial implementations, 2014: p. 479-486.

Lucarelli, C.D.C. and J.C. Carlo, Parametric modeling simulation for an origami shaped canopy. Frontiers of Architectural Research, 2020. 9(1): p. 67-81.

Baghoolizadeh, M., et al., Multi-objective optimization of Venetian blinds in office buildings to reduce electricity consumption and improve visual and thermal comfort by NSGA-II. Energy and Buildings, 2023. 278: p. 112639.

Dev, G. and A. Saifudeen, Dynamic facade control systems for optimal daylighting, a case of Kerala. Sustainability Analytics and Modeling, 2023. 3: p. 100018.

Jakica, N., State-of-the-art review of solar design tools and methods for assessing daylighting and solar potential for building-integrated photovoltaics. Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews, 2018. 81: p. 1296-1328.

Lotfabadi, P. and P. Hançer, Optimization of visual comfort: Building openings. Journal of Building Engineering, 2023. 72: p. 106598.

Ma’bdeh, S. and B. Al-Khatatbeh, Daylighting retrofit methods as a tool for enhancing daylight provision in existing educational spaces—A case study. Buildings, 2019. 9(7): p. 159.

Cibse, L.G. and S.L.L.L. Guide, 5: Lighting for education. Chartered Institution of Building Services Engineers, London, 2011.

Cen, E.N., 12464-1 Light and lighting-Lighting of work places-Part 1: Indoor work places. European Committee for Standardization (CEN), Brussels, 2011.

Pandey, P. and M.M. Pandey, Research methodology tools and techniques. 2021: Bridge Center.

Konstantzos, I., et al., The effect of lighting environment on task performance in buildings–A review. Energy and Buildings, 2020. 226: p. 110394.

Antony, J., Design of experiments for engineers and scientists. 2023: Elsevier.

Teo, Y.H., et al., A simulation-aided approach in examining the viability of passive daylighting techniques on inclined windows. Energy and Buildings, 2023. 282: p. 112739.

Lechner, N., Heating, cooling, lighting: Sustainable design methods for architects. 2014: John wiley & sons.

Doberneck, D. and K. Knechtel. Heliodon: A hands-on daylighting educational tool.

Salgado-Conrado, L., et al., Review of Heliodon Developments and Computational Tools for Building Shadow Analysis. Buildings, 2022. 12(5): p. 627.

Blouch, N., et al., Economic Feasibility of Energy Saving by Incorporating Daylight: A Case Study of College Building in Multan-Pakistan. Technical Journal, 2021. 26(02): p. 67-80.

Kalaimathy, K., et al., Daylight performance analysis of a residential building in a tropical climate. Energy Nexus, 2023. 11: p. 100226.

Baydoğan, M.Ç. and V. Özkantar, Evaluation of Daylight Performance Metrics According to Country Guidelines: The Case of Educational Buildings in Turkey. Energy and Buildings, 2023: p. 113487.

Jamala, N., R.A. Mangkuto, and B. Paramita, Uncertainty analysis of annual daylight metrics and energy yield weighting factors in optimising photovoltaic window orientation. Solar Energy, 2023. 262: p. 111901.

ÇElİK, T. and İ. Nurgül, Daylight in Library Design and Natural Light Distribution: Ostim Technical University Library. STAR Sanat ve Tasarım Araştırmaları Dergisi, 2023. 4(6): p. 70-89.

Alkhatatbeh, B.J., Y. Kurdi, and S. Asadi, Multi-Objective Optimization of Classrooms’ Daylight Performance and Energy Use in US Climate Zones. Energy and Buildings, 2023: p. 113468.

Knoop, M., et al., Daylight: What makes the difference? Lighting Research & Technology, 2020. 52(3): p. 423-442.